Skin Deep Conversations…

Lately, many thoughts on skin pigment have weighed heavy on my mind, mostly sparked by several related conversations and incidents, most of which were with young people who have been indoctrinated to despise their own skin, if only on a subconscious level. Their young, malleable minds have been proselytized by the socially constructed lies within the messages that bombard them every single day, whether subliminal or out right aggressive. It’s heartbreaking.

And I’m just a white dude. What words of weight do I have to offer in this situation? I tip-toe around the taboo-ness of the topic in my mind, knowing that I was born into a race that was unfairly and ignorantly set as the “standard”. It disgusts me to even write that. Yet, I remember growing up, having several teachers who referred to the peach colored crayon as Flesh. Flesh?

The audacity of naming one color (yes, indeed the color matching the skin of Caucasians) Flesh is sickening and absurd (The Crayola color now known as Peach was officially changed to that from Flesh in 1962); an entire box of crayons could not contain the many various flesh tones in this world. However, little white kids could hold that “Flesh” colored crayon up to their little arms and see the match, cruelly confirming that sense of deeply instilled white superiority, “Yes, flesh,” whilst the little darker brown kids could hold up the very same crayon to their little arms, and rather than telling them something about the color of the crayon, they are told something about the color of their flesh, “Not flesh.” They’re stuck with Burnt Sienna, whatever that is.

Sure, things have changed since I was in elementary school. I was born in 1980. It’s 2012. But as much as things have changed, they have also just stayed the same, stagnated. Why is the standard-color of a Bandaid still the color of that crayon that was labelled as Flesh? Bandaids are meant to cover up a wound, but also blend in with the skin to conceal it. (I am aware that Bandaids for darker complexions are sold, but they are not as openly available, and definitely not the “norm”.) Have you ever seen a standard-color Bandaid on the skin of a dark brown person?

It doesn’t really blend in.

I have spoken to many people, of many shades of brown, about the topic of Bandaids, as a more subtle and accepted form of systemic racism in our society. A large amount of them feel that I am looking into it too deeply; admittedly, most of those people were people whose flesh conveniently conceals a standard-color Bandaid. To me, the fact that this is the “norm”, that it is “acceptable”, that it is “no big deal”, that we are completely calloused to it, shows me just how deep the indoctrination of the skin pigment heiarchy goes in all of us.

Way deeper than skin deep, to say the least.

My eleven-year-old neighbor Carl was sitting beside me the other day. He was born in Trinidad, but has lived in America most of his life. He has rich brown skin, and his head is covered with a thick offering of jet-black hair. Carl stroked my arm, and seemingly out of the blue said, “I wish I had white skin.”

I was surprised by his statement, “Why?”

Carl, “It’s more beautiful than black skin.”

Me, “That’s not true. Why do you say that?”

Carl, “Black skin is ugly.”

Me, “Not true. Who told you that?”

Carl, “I see it.”

I touched his arm, “I see it too. And dark brown skin looks beautiful to me.”

Unconsolable, Carl shifted the conversation slightly, “Black people are bad.”

At this point, I would have thought he was just saying things to say things and get answers, if I had not heard the seriousness in his voice, felt it in his eyes.

“Carl, that is untrue and a huge generalization. Some black people do bad things, but some white people do bad things too. People of all races do.”

Carl, “But white people are all good!”

Me, “Also very untrue, and another generalization. White people are the ones who brought black people over to America as slaves, Carl. That’s not good.”

Carl, “But that’s not now.”

We spoke about how the “then” impacts the “now”, and about generalizations. Carl tried to convince me he was not generalizing, “But all I see is black people doing bad things!”

Me, “Where?”

Carl, “In our neighborhood, on the movies! Shooting, killing, doing bad things!”

I gently reminded him that we live in a neighborhood that is populated predominantly by black people, and that is why it is “all he sees”, but if he were to go to neighborhoods where other races are the majority, he would also see them doing “bad things”. I assured him that where I am from, and elsewhere all over the world, there are many, many white people who do bad things.

Carl seemed unconvinced, so I did a Google Image search for “Caucasian mugshot” and we scrolled through the hundreds of white people who had done “bad things”. Slightly more persuaded, I then got him to admit that most of the “good” he experiences in his life is also done by black people, seeing that the vast majority of his interactions are in his neighborhood.

Carl quickly switched over to his movies anecdote, and I quickly rebutted by saying that movies are not real life. I wasn’t sure if he was ready for the conversation about who controls Hollywood in the first place, and what their agenda is. I rather asked him what race the majority of the killers are in the horror films that he loves to watch: Freddy, Jason, Michael Myers, the dude from Saw, all the ghosts in pretty much every movie ever…Caucasian. All of them. He got the picture.

Our conversation moved on to why people have different color skin, slavery, why Carl wants to marry a white lady, white people getting sunburned, hair that grows on arms, and eventually men with mustaches and at what point a boy can expect to be able to grow one. It was all downhill from there.

That conversation with Carl validated that his perceptions and attitudes towards skin are no different to the findings of the Doll Study conducted by the Clarks in the 1940s, the same attitudes and perceptions found amongst young people of color in Kiri Davis’s short documentary A Girl Like Me; the terrible idea that “white is good, black is bad,” or “white is beautiful, black is ugly”. Truly tragic.

And little dark-skinned girls bleach their skin to make it lighter, and relax their hair to make it more “acceptable”, all to fit into this image they are told is “ideal”. Ironically, on the other side of the spectrum, white women pay for expensive products, get spray-on tans, and bake in the sun for hours, all so their skin will be a darker shade of brown, a color that will only last as long as their products do, or as long as the sun decides it is his season to shine. This makes me think that white supremacist views were probably founded in the idolization of beautiful dark brown skin, the lustful desire to have deep, colored, flawless skin with no visible blemishes, with no beginning and no end. Hatred is often rooted in jealousy.

That discussion with Carl was direct and to the point, but I witness the same conversation taking more of a meta-communicative form in many of the exchanges and interactions I hear and see the neighborhood kids have with each other on a daily basis. James gets dogged-on every single day for how dark his skin is. The jokes are way beyond endearing, and are usually just plain mean, not to mention unprovoked.

James is fourteen. He’s originally from Guyana but has lived in America most of his life. His skin is a beautiful, perfect, deep, dark brown. Fortunately for James, he seems to be proud of his complexion, and therefore shrugs off the jeering comments as “ignorant”. But that’s just James.

Who taught these kids to loathe dark skin? Who taught Carl that “white is good, and black is bad”? I’m sure no one sat them down and taught them these things directly. More likely, it is in the messages the media pummels them with daily, in the dialogue of their elders, in the “history” they learn in school, in the sickening pop culture that continues to worship “all that is white” whether admitted or not, in their interactions with police and other authority figures, and in the subtleties of their day-to-day interactions with the world.

Subtleties that tell us that “white lies” are acceptable, but “dark secrets” are not.

Subtleties beneath a certain color being called “flesh”.

Subtleties of a dark-skinned child falling down, getting a cut on his knee, and covering it with a Bandaid whose color and form stand out exaggeratedly, because it was made for a person of a lighter complexion, a complexion that has unfairly, unjustly, and wrongly been set as the “ideal” complexion, the “standard”.

These subtleties can only remain subtle if we continue to allow them to. We can, indeed, call them out, exposing the lies that have guided our social interactions for so long. And I feel it is our responsibility to do just that. Carl needs to know that all shades of brown are beautiful, and it is not our skin that determines how “good” or “bad” we are, but contrarily our motives, thoughts and intentions on the inside, which lead to our outward actions.

I’m going to need Grace Jones to to run around shouting, “Black is beautiful,” with a boombox blaring India Arie’s Brown Skin, stat!


5 Responses to Skin Deep Conversations…

  1. Krista says:

    Your conversations bring back a number of childhood memories for me. I am in agreement with some of your thoughts, but others, I feel as though I’m on the other side of the coin. I too had the same experience with the crayon as a child in elementary school. At some point, I think I did put it up to my own skin to make a comparison, but then when I used the crayon in my drawings, I never felt like it made my drawings believable, nor did I think that any shade of brown made them believable as well. I think we need better crayons.

    With regards to the band-aids… may be just me, I guess I’ve just become accustomed to the color that it really never bothered me. I remember the arguments about the color of the band aids in the past, being flesh colored, and I do understand the premise behind the argument, but for me, at the end of the day, I just need to stop my wound from bleeding more.

    I feel like I want to respond to so much, but that would take forever. I don’t want to speak for all blacks, or black women, but as light skin black woman growing up in the Midwest, color was definitely an issue among those in my school. I was the only black girl in my elementary school from 1st to 6th grade. When I moved on to middle school, high school, and college, my color became an issue among the black community. Being light skin was apparently better….which in my brain, I could care less, but nevertheless, it was an issue. Now that I wear my hair naturally, that’s an issue, not only with whites, but blacks. It’s an emotionally degrading feeling to be told that as a black woman, it’s unprofessional for me to wear my natural hair to work, and to be told this by your black supervisor.

    Again…..I feel like I’m on both sides of the fence in some of the issues you’ve brought up. Some of them, I’m not bothered by, just because I know that racism, unfortunately, will always exist…..but I also feel like….these aren’t things that I give power to in my life. No one’s going to make me believe that my skin color isn’t beautiful…..the hair….a different issue, and that opens a can of worms, that I struggle with every day. Anyhoo….I feel as though I’m rambling.

  2. Krista says:

    Actually….I started thinking about this some more. I believe that blacks (Africans and African Americans) have to address the self hatred within our race and culture, before we can begin to racial issues that we experience from other races.

  3. Krista says:

    typo….before we can begin to **address** racial issues that we experience from other races.

  4. jessica gribble says:

    I was raised by a half italian, half puerto rican women. My father is black with a little bit if indian in him. A while ago, like it’s been months, my mom and I somehow got on the conversation of skin color and I remembering saying that I was black. And to my shock she told me that I wasn’t. Ok, answer me this, how can someone say that their child is not black when they obviously had sex with a black man??? Well, I of course told her that yes I was and we argued about it! It was the most ridiculous argument I ever had. And we still argue over it. But what I’ve realized now is that she is only looking at the color of my skin and ignoring my ethnicity. Because I’m light skinned, that makes me white. If I were black, I would be darker.

    A few weeks ago when we had the gender reveal party, I had brought up the fact that I was excited to have a black baby. And of course my mother tells me that my child is not going to be black. Really? This time I was pissed. So I asked her, how is my child not going to be black when his father is obviously black!? Her response was because I’m white and light skinned. She said that since she lived in new york she’s seen it all. She’s seen a white woman and a black man have a white baby. And that she’s seen black couples have white babies. So for me it is possible that my child is going to be white and not black. So I pointed out that my father in law is the darkest on his side of the family and then told her to look at jac, who is the darkest of all the family! And both his parents were black. She didn’t care and said that that didn’t matter and that my child was going to be white. That’s when I realized that she’s only basing things off color and not ethnicity. But if we want to get technical about “skin color,” I’m not white, I’m caramel! As I like to consider myself. Or according to the paint color section at lowes, my skin color matches pale blush.
    about someone who’s racist, someone being classified as a colored girl, or someone who doesn’t like someone else because of color of their skin. It’s bullshit! Sorry haha. But it is! It’s sickening to learn how ignorant people really are and more sickening to talk to people to who deny that it happens.

    My prayer, that my child turns out to be so “black” that he actually matches thecrayon color black!

  5. jessica gribble says:

    I’m 25 and everyday it seems like I’m always hearing about someone who’s racist, someone being classified as a colored girl, or someone who doesn’t like someone else because of color of their skin. It’s bullshit! Sorry haha. But it is! It’s sickening to learn how ignorant people really are and more sickening to talk to people to who deny that it happens.

    My prayer, that my child turns out to be so “black” that he actually matches the crayon color black!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: